Multiply your furnace's age by the repair cost. If the result is over 5,000, replacement deserves a serious look. If it's under about 3,500, repair is usually the better value. Safety overrides the math: a cracked heat exchanger or carbon monoxide problem usually means replace.
Try the calculator
Repair or replace? Try the $5,000 rule
My furnace is years old, and the repair quote is $.
Above 5,000, the money spent on repairs often goes further toward a new, more efficient furnace. Ask for both prices before deciding.
How the $5,000 rule works
The rule combines two things that matter most, how old the furnace is and how much the repair costs, into one number:
| Example | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 8-year-old furnace, $350 igniter | 2,800 | Repair |
| 12-year-old furnace, $350 repair | 4,200 | Borderline: compare both |
| 16-year-old furnace, $400 repair | 6,400 | Get a replacement quote |
| 20-year-old furnace, $900 blower motor | 18,000 | Replacement likely makes sense |
It's a rule of thumb, not a law. Use it to start the conversation, then weigh the factors below.
Five factors beyond the math
1. Safety
A cracked heat exchanger, flame rollout or carbon monoxide readings usually mean replacement, whatever the score. Ask for evidence: photos, camera footage, CO readings. See heat exchanger repair.
2. Repair history
Two or more significant repairs in two years suggests more are coming. Add up what you've spent recently.
3. Age and remaining life
Most gas furnaces last about 15–20 years. A furnace near the end of that range will need more repairs soon. See how long furnaces last in Texas.
4. Comfort
Cold rooms, short cycling or a furnace that can't keep up in a freeze may mean it was never sized right, and a new, properly sized system fixes that.
5. Efficiency and the AC
An older furnace paired with an aging AC (especially original R-22 equipment, which is no longer produced) is a strong case for replacing both together.
When to repair, even on an older furnace
- The repair is inexpensive (flame sensor cleaning, a capacitor, a switch)
- The furnace has a clean safety inspection and few past repairs
- You plan to sell soon, or replace the whole system next year on your own schedule
Get both numbers in writing. A trustworthy contractor will quote the repair and, if it makes sense, a replacement, and let you decide. See our furnace replacement service.